Last night, I watched all of Phish doing “No Reply at All” at the March 15 Hall of Fame festivities. Having now seen both both of the Genesis covers, I agree with what appears to be the consensus – Phish nailed “Watcher,” but “No Reply” was, as they used to say at a camp where I once worked, “fair to poor.”
That’s not to say I wouldn’t be quite pleased if the band busted out “No Reply” out at Merriweather on June 26.
Anyway, with a hat tip to YEMblog, here’s a good quality video of “Watcher of the Skies” for the record.
